How to Repair a Shower Faucet That Refuses to Shut Off

If you’ve ever been in a situation where you couldn’t turn off your shower faucet, you know how frustrating it can be. Whether it’s a stubborn handle or a faulty valve, a shower faucet that won’t turn off can lead to an unnecessary waste of water and energy. However, fixing this common problem is easier than you might think.

Step 1: Identify the Issue

Before you can fix your shower faucet, you need to determine the cause of the problem. In most cases, a shower faucet that won’t turn off is due to a faulty cartridge or valve. You may also want to check if there are any mineral deposits or debris blocking the flow of water. By identifying the issue, you’ll be able to choose the right solution.

Step 2: Turn off the Water Supply

Before you begin working on your shower faucet, it’s crucial to turn off the water supply. This will prevent any accidental leaks or water damage. Look for the shut-off valve, usually located near the shower or in the basement, and turn it clockwise until it’s fully closed. If you can’t find the shut-off valve, consider shutting off the main water supply to your house.

Step 3: Disassemble the Faucet

Once you’ve turned off the water supply, it’s time to disassemble the faucet. Start by removing the handle using a screwdriver or an Allen wrench, depending on the type of handle. Then, unscrew the escutcheon plate and remove it. You should now have access to the cartridge or valve.

Step 4: Replace the Faulty Part

If the issue is a faulty cartridge or valve, you’ll need to replace it. Consult the manufacturer’s instructions or a plumbing professional to ensure you choose the right replacement part. Remove the old cartridge or valve and insert the new one. Reassemble the faucet in the reverse order, making sure everything is tightly secured.

Step 5: Test the Faucet

After reassembling the faucet, turn on the water supply and test if the shower faucet now turns off properly. If everything is working correctly, you can enjoy your shower without any worries. However, if the problem persists, you may need to consult a professional plumber who can assess and fix any underlying issues.

By following these steps, you can successfully fix a shower faucet that won’t turn off and save yourself from the frustration of a constantly running shower. Remember to exercise caution and, if needed, seek professional help to ensure a proper and long-lasting fix.

Diagnosing the Problem

When you have a shower faucet that won’t turn off, it can be quite frustrating. However, before you can fix the problem, you need to diagnose what might be causing it. Here are a few common issues to check for:

  • Shower handle is loose or broken: If the handle is loose or broken, it may not be able to turn the faucet off completely. Inspect the handle to see if it needs tightening or if it is broken and needs to be replaced.
  • Worn-out cartridge: The shower faucet may have a cartridge that controls the flow of water. Over time, the cartridge can wear out, leading to a faucet that won’t turn off. You can try taking out the cartridge and replacing it to see if that solves the problem.
  • Faulty valve seat: The valve seat is the connection between the faucet and the spout. If the valve seat is damaged or worn out, it can cause leaks and prevent the faucet from turning off completely. Inspect the valve seat and replace it if necessary.
  • Buildup of mineral deposits: Over time, mineral deposits can accumulate in the faucet and affect its performance. These deposits can prevent the faucet from turning off completely. Try cleaning the faucet with a descaling solution to remove any mineral buildup.
  • Faulty diverter valve: If you have a shower and bathtub combination, the diverter valve controls the flow of water between the two. A faulty diverter valve can cause leaks and prevent the faucet from turning off. Inspect the diverter valve and replace it if needed.

By checking these common issues, you can begin to diagnose the problem with your shower faucet that won’t turn off. Once you have identified the cause, you can then take the necessary steps to fix it and get your faucet working properly again.

Evaluating the Faucet Handle

The first step in fixing a shower faucet that won’t turn off is to evaluate the faucet handle. Inspect the handle to see if it is loose or damaged. A loose handle may not be allowing the faucet to fully turn off, while a damaged handle could be causing the issue.

If the handle is loose, try tightening the screws or bolts that hold it in place. Use a screwdriver or wrench to secure the handle and see if this resolves the problem. If the handle continues to be loose, it may need to be replaced.

Inspect the handle for any visible damage, such as cracks or breaks. If the handle is damaged, it will likely need to be replaced. You can find replacement handles at most hardware or home improvement stores. Make sure to purchase a handle that is compatible with your specific shower faucet model.

It’s also worth checking if the handle is aligned properly. Over time, the handle may become misaligned, preventing it from turning off completely. Adjust the handle so that it is aligned correctly with the faucet body.

Once you have evaluated the faucet handle and made any necessary adjustments or replacements, test the faucet to see if it now turns off properly. If the problem persists, there may be an issue with the faucet cartridge or valve, which may require further troubleshooting or professional assistance.

Table: Evaluating the Faucet Handle

IssuePossible Solutions
Loose handleTighten screws or bolts
Replace handle if needed
Damaged handleReplace handle with compatible one
Misaligned handleAdjust handle to align properly with faucet body

Checking the Water Supply Valves

Before attempting to fix a shower faucet that won’t turn off, it’s important to check the water supply valves to ensure they are functioning correctly. These valves control the flow of water to the faucet and can sometimes become stuck or faulty, causing water to continuously run or not shut off completely.

To check the water supply valves, follow these steps:

  1. Locate the water supply valves. These valves are typically located under the sink or behind the shower wall.
  2. Turn off the main water supply. This will prevent any water from flowing while you inspect the valves.
  3. Inspect the valves for any signs of damage or corrosion. If the valves are damaged or corroded, they may need to be replaced.
  4. Slowly turn the valves clockwise to shut off the water supply. If the valves are difficult to turn or do not fully shut off the water, they may need to be repaired or replaced.
  5. If the valves appear to be functioning correctly, turn on the main water supply and check if the shower faucet still won’t turn off. If the issue persists, it may be a problem with the faucet itself.

Checking the water supply valves is an important step in troubleshooting a shower faucet that won’t turn off. If the valves are not working properly, it may be necessary to contact a plumber for further assistance.

Inspecting the Cartridge

One of the common causes of a shower faucet that won’t turn off is a faulty cartridge. The cartridge is responsible for controlling the flow of water and ensuring that the valve is properly closed when the handle is turned off.

To inspect the cartridge, you will need to remove the handle and trim sleeve of the faucet. Use a screwdriver or an Allen wrench to remove the screws holding the trim sleeve in place. Once the trim sleeve is removed, you should see the cartridge located inside the valve body.

Inspect the cartridge for any signs of damage or wear. Look for cracks, breaks, or worn-out components. If you notice any issues, it is likely that the cartridge needs to be replaced.

In some cases, the cartridge may be clogged with mineral deposits or debris, which can also prevent the faucet from fully turning off. Use a soft brush or toothbrush to clean the cartridge thoroughly. Make sure to remove any obstructions that may be blocking the flow of water.

Once you have inspected and cleaned the cartridge, reassemble the faucet by placing the trim sleeve back in place and tightening the screws. Turn the water supply back on and test the faucet to see if it turns off properly.

If the cartridge is still causing issues after cleaning, it may be necessary to replace it. Contact a professional plumber or refer to the manufacturer’s instructions for guidance on finding the correct replacement cartridge for your shower faucet.

Inspecting the cartridge is an important step in fixing a shower faucet that won’t turn off. By identifying any damage or obstructions, you can determine the appropriate solution to restore proper functionality to your shower faucet.

Replacing the Cartridge

If you’ve determined that the problem lies with the cartridge of your shower faucet, it’s time to replace it. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you get it done:

1. Turn off the water supply to the shower faucet. You can usually find the shut-off valve near the shower or in the basement.

2. Remove the handle of the shower faucet. This can usually be done by unscrewing a small screw or using a screwdriver to pry off a cover plate.

3. Once the handle is removed, you should see the cartridge. Use a pair of pliers or a cartridge removal tool to carefully pull it out.

4. Take the old cartridge with you to a hardware store to ensure you get an exact replacement.

5. Install the new cartridge by carefully sliding it into the valve body. Make sure it’s aligned properly and push it in until it’s fully seated.

6. Reattach the handle of the shower faucet and tighten any screws or cover plates.

7. Turn on the water supply and test the shower faucet to ensure it’s working properly.

If the problem persists even after replacing the cartridge, you may need to call a professional plumber to further diagnose and fix the issue.

Calling a Professional

If you’ve tried all the DIY methods and your shower faucet still won’t turn off, it may be time to call a professional plumber. A licensed plumber will have the expertise and experience to diagnose and fix the problem efficiently and effectively.

When calling a professional, make sure to provide them with detailed information about the problem. For example, mention if the faucet is leaking while the water is running or if it continues to drip even when turned off. This information will help the plumber better understand the issue and come prepared with the necessary tools and parts.

Hiring a professional plumber may cost more than attempting to fix the problem yourself, but it can save you time, frustration, and potential damage to your shower or plumbing system. Plus, a professional can ensure that the repair is done correctly, reducing the likelihood of future issues.

Keep in mind that some shower faucet problems may require replacing certain parts or even the entire faucet. A professional plumber will be able to assess the situation and provide you with the best course of action. They can also recommend high-quality replacement parts if needed.

Remember, attempting to fix a complicated plumbing issue without the proper knowledge or tools can lead to further damage and costly repairs. So, if you’re unsure or uncomfortable with the process, don’t hesitate to call a professional plumber. They will handle the problem with expertise and ensure that your shower faucet is back to working properly.

Video:,

Tub spout diverter how to fix , from beginning to the end. Using the Danco repair kit.

Water Not Coming Out Of Shower Head? Tub Spout Diverter Repair

Photo of author

Ryan Pietrzak

Ryan Pietrzak, a licensed plumber with 12+ years of experience, is the trusted expert behind Plumbing.Academy. With a wealth of practical knowledge, Ryan guides you through plumbing challenges, making informed decisions easier. His reputable advice, rooted in real-world expertise, empowers both DIY enthusiasts and seasoned plumbers.